Site Tools


author:catespoints

Feedback from Cate

Just trying to build a list of the feedback that we've received from Cate.

Email Feedback After Chapter 1

  • Avoid using “this,” “these,” etc. by themselves (as pronouns); your sentences will be clearer if you follow them with a noun.
  • I'm deleting virtually all exclamation points.
  • Avoid using ampersands, even when space is tight.
  • Any questions about my “remarks”? The first one was about heading structure; I recommend reviewing the other chapters for the same issue. (This was in regards to Chapter 1.)
  • My first impulse was to start doing away with italics, but I stopped because it looked like you're using them in an expanded application of O'Reilly style for first mention of technical terms - you're using them for everyday terms and names in a social media context (see below). Still not sure you need them, though; it might get a little old by Chapter 6.
  • Here are my style notes so far:
    • <eBay seller's> Feedback score
    • explicit reputation statement
    • global reputation
  • italics: use not only to introduce technical terms but to introduce known terms, names, or categories in the context of social media
    • reputable entities
    • reputation statement
    • Web 2.0
  • Will you have a glossary of some kind?

Some Positive Feedback Between Chaps 1 & 2

  • Not riddled with passive voice
  • Not laced with passages that I couldn't understand (in Chapter 1 there was only one paragraph I couldn't rewrite)

Feedback given after Chapter 2

Feedback After Chapter 4

Feedback After Chapter 5

  • Overall, italics and caps are used too much to be effective in highlighting things, so in this chapter I took out a lot of italics and lowercased a lot of capitalized words. Most of the time this worked - i.e., the terms were actually easier to grasp without the extra italics and caps treatment - but in a few cases I had to change the wording, e.g., “the <i>Helpful</i> claim” didn't work as “the helpful claim,” so I changed it to “the was-this-helpful claim.”
  • Are you planning to include a glossary? If you are that would be a really, really good thing.
  • Please see additions and changes to attached stylesheet, including the last section on overall changes.
author/catespoints.txt · Last modified: by 127.0.0.1